New York rent vs. buy calculator

The honest break-even — counting what it costs to sell, and what the down payment would have earned if it stayed invested. Both are usually left out, and both favour renting.

Pre-filled with New York’s own sourced figures: a $480,000 median home, a 1.45% effective property tax rate, $1,710 average insurance, and 4.4% annual appreciation. Rent is seeded from HUD FY2026 two-bedroom fair market rent, median across 39 FMR areas in New York. Change anything that does not match your situation.
Buying
Renting

Continue calculating

Related reading

Guides & templates