New Mexico rental property calculator

Cap rate, real cash flow, and return on the cash you put in — including the expenses most analyses leave out. Estimate only, not investment advice.

The property

Operating costs

Financing

Estimates only — not investment, tax, or legal advice. How we calculate every figure

New Mexico guide

Rental Property in New Mexico: What the Numbers Actually Look Like

  • New Mexico's filed rate change was a mild +2.4% from 2024 to 2025, and that figure is misleading. Cumulative 2020-2025 is +45.8%, Insurify projects roughly +11% for 2026, and the state Superintendent of Insurance reported insurers declined to renew a RECORD number of homes in 2025. Non-renewal, not price, is how this market is adjusting.
  • The published premiums genuinely disagree. Insurance.com's cross-state table reads $3,497 while Insurance.com's own New Mexico page reads $2,869 — same publisher, two numbers, a $628 gap. Insurify reads $3,348 and Insure.com $2,638. The recorded $3,088 is the midpoint of a band running roughly $2,500 to $3,500, worth 0.24 points of cap rate.
  • New Mexico HAS a FAIR Plan, which most Western states do not — but it writes fire, extended coverage, and vandalism only. No liability. No loss of rents. For a landlord that is not a substitute policy, it is a partial one.

The most important number in New Mexico's insurance data is one you cannot read off a rate table.

The state's filed home-insurance rate change from 2024 to 2025 was +2.4% — well below the 6.0% national figure, and on its face a sign of an unusually calm market. It is not. In the same period New Mexico's cumulative 2020-2025 rate change was +45.8%, Insurify projects roughly +11% for 2026 on wildfire activity, and — this is the one that matters — the New Mexico Office of Superintendent of Insurance reported that insurers declined to renew a record number of homes in 2025.

Non-renewal, not price, has been this market's main adjustment mechanism. That is exactly why a filed rate change understates the pressure, and it is a different risk from an expensive premium. An expensive premium is a line item you can underwrite. A non-renewal is a property you can no longer insure on the terms your lender requires, arriving with 30 to 45 days' notice, on a house you have a tenant in.

New Mexico does have a FAIR Plan, which most Western states do not. Section 2 explains why that is genuinely good news and also why, for a landlord specifically, it is not the safety net it sounds like: it writes fire, extended coverage, and vandalism. No liability. No loss of rents.

A note before you start: this is general educational information about how rental property arithmetic works in New Mexico. It is not investment, tax, insurance, or legal advice, and it is not a recommendation about any property. Talk to a New Mexico CPA about tax treatment, a licensed New Mexico agent about a real quote, and a New Mexico attorney about anything contractual.

1. What a rental costs to buy here

The statewide median sold price is $357,000 (New Mexico Association of Realtors, July 2026, up more than 10% year over year). Redfin's March 2026 read was $378,300 and Zillow's smoothed index $314,851; the Realtor closed-sale figure is used here.

Read the full New Mexico guide →20 min read · Updated 2026-08-28